Wayside Market · Southold, NY · Since 1963
Fall Tastes Better at Our Table.
Sunday roasts, slow-simmered braciole, game day spreads and breakfast for the whole crew. Cold nights, full tables. You bring the people, we’ll handle the food.
An Intimate Affair
Elevated Single Dinners
A restaurant-worthy dinner, enjoyed in the comfort of your own home.
$42.99per person · great for one to four people
Entrée Course
- Herb & Garlic Crusted Lamb RoastGrilled, with a delicate rosemary gravy.
- House Aged SteakMarinated or unmarinated. Want one steak for two or four? Just ask when you order.
- ¼ Herbes de Provence Roasted Chicken
Single Dinner Sides
1 side is included. 2 sides are an additional $7.00 each.
- Horseradish Whipped Potatoes
- Sautéed Garden SpinachWith garlic and herbs.
- Regular Pommes FritesSkin on.
- Sweet Potato Pommes FritesSkin on, served with an optional maple aioli.
- Cucumber Tzatziki Salad
Mornings, Handled
Breakfast & Brunch
¼ Tray · Feeds 2–4½ Tray · Feeds 6–8Full Tray · Feeds 10–12
Hot Breakfast
- Grandpa’s French ToastThick cut, served with a spiced butter and maple syrup. Classic, stuffed, or chocolate.
- Southern Biscuits & GravyCountry-style buttery biscuits with our homemade sage sausage gravy.
- PancakesFluffy, with a spiced butter. Classic, strawberry, banana, chocolate chip, or chocolate chip walnut.
Breakfast for Champions
Simple servings of the classics for any gathering, small or large.
Eggs Your Way
On the Side
Egg Sandwich Platters
Wrapped for a quick and easy grab-and-go.
Meat
Bread
Continental Breakfast
Assorted Baked Goods
Creamy sweet honey butter available upon request for the sweet corn muffins.
Assorted Bagels
With cream cheese, butter, and jams.
Lox Passing Platter
Small feeds 2–4 · Large feeds 6–10
- Fresh lox, pickled onions, capers, shaved cucumbers, cornichons, tomatoes, and cream cheese spread.
Assorted Morning Health Bowls
Coffee & Beverages
- A Box of JoeBulk coffee, iced or hot, your call.
- Homemade Iced Tea & LemonadeOr half and half. Available upon request.
Game Day & Get-Togethers
Starters
¼ Tray · Feeds 2–4½ Tray · Feeds 6–8Full Tray · Feeds 10–12
Sliders
- Crab Cake SlidersOur classic slaw and a thick Cajun serving sauce.
- Feta & Mint Mediterranean Chicken SlidersWith a yogurt cucumber dill sauce.
- Pull-Apart Mexican Street Corn Dip SlidersWith a spicy chorizo sausage.
- Pulled Pork SlidersWith a crunchy Asian broccoli slaw.
- Korean Beef BulgogiCrunchy cucumber, kimchi, and a tangy special sauce aioli.
Passing Hors d’Oeuvres
- BBQ / Cajun Islander Ribs
- BBQ MeatballsWith cheesy grits and braised greens.
- Fresh BruschettaOn crostini toast points with a fig balsamic glaze.
- Fresh Herb Goat Cheese CakesWith arugula and fig balsamic.
Grazing Table & Platters
- The Roman-Greco PlatterAn epic combination of Mediterranean gourmet foods and spreads, local fresh fruits and/or vegetables, delicious cheese, and our pasture-raised Italian-style cured meats.
- Local Crudité PlatterLocal vegetables with hummus or a green goddess dressing.
- Fruit & Cheese PlatterThe juiciest fruit, served with honey and our highest quality cheese.
- Fruit PlatterJuicy fresh fruit displayed for simple eating.
Feed the Whole Crew
Gatherings
¼ Tray · Feeds 2–4½ Tray · Feeds 6–8Full Tray · Feeds 10–12
Sunday Dinner
Gluten free options available.
- Braciole Simmered in Grandma’s SauceYour choice of pork, beef, or veal, simmered for several hours.
- Meatballs
- Lasagna
- Baked ZitiVegetable, beef, or traditional cheese.
- Beef Pasta
Garlic semolina bread available upon request.
Tailgate & Backyard BBQ
- Aged Steak PackageHouse aged steak of the week, truffled parmigiano pommes frites, and a local grilled or sautéed vegetable of the week.
- Hot Dog / Burger PackageSteamed dirty dogs and freshly hand-packed Wayside burgers with all the fixings.
- KabobsBeef, lamb, pork, or chicken skewered with local vegetables.
- BBQ Pork Ribs or Beef Ribs
- BBQ Short Ribs
- Pulled Pork
- Fried Chicken
Sicilian Affair
- Local catch of the day broiled in parchment with local vegetables and a cheesy garlic polenta.
The Main Event
Sunday Roast
The centerpiece your table has been waiting for. Reserve yours with a deposit.
- Prime-Aged Prime Rib Roast (Tied Back)$100 deposit
- Braised Short Ribs$100 deposit
- Pork & Beef Braciole Slow Cooked in Sauce$100 deposit
- Leg of Lamb$100 deposit
- Rack of Lamb (½ or Full)$100 deposit
- Lamb Loin Roast$100 deposit
- Roasted Duck L’Orange$100 deposit
- Organic Herb Roasted Chicken
Organic herb roasted chicken is roasted whole or butterflied for easy service.
Accompaniments
Sides & Salads
¼ Tray · Feeds 2–4½ Tray · Feeds 6–8Full Tray · Feeds 10–12
Classic Sides
- Our Gooey Baked Mac & Cheese
- Grandma’s Stewed Green BeansWith garden tomatoes.
- Traditional Whipped Potatoes
- Garlic Whipped Mashed Potatoes
- Grilled Garden Vegetables
- Herb Roasted Pommes FritesSkin on.
- Truffled Parmesan Roasted Sweet Potato Pommes FritesSkin on, served with an optional maple aioli.
Salads
Some salads may be gluten free upon request. Additional protein available upon request.
- Italian Chopped SaladGreens, red onions, olives, aged salami, banana peppers, cucumbers, and tomatoes.
- Cobb SaladGreens, bacon, eggs, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers.
- German Potato SaladVinegar based, served warm or room temperature.
- Dutch Potato SaladMayonnaise based, served cold.
- Sausage, Broccoli & Garlic Pesto Pasta Salad
- Curried Chicken SaladWith grapes and walnuts.
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
- Beet SaladFresh local beets, extra virgin olive oil, vinegar, salt, and pepper to taste.
More Salads
- Caprese Caesar Pasta SaladPasta, bruschetta, fresh mozzarella, basil, pesto, dressing.
- BLT Pasta SaladPasta, green goddess ranch, bacon, tomato, avocado, and sweet corn when available.
- Mediterranean Pasta SaladPasta, olives, feta, cucumbers, red onions, dressing.
- Italian Pasta SaladOlives, aged provolone, and dressing.
- Classic Macaroni Salad
- Classic Coleslaw
- Crunchy Asian SlawRed cabbage and carrots tossed with sesame oil and rice vinegar.
- Cucumber Avocado SaladCucumber, avocado, radicchio, red onions, parsley, lightly dressed.
- Cucumber Yogurt SaladWith red onions, a hint of citrus, and radish.
- Simple Cucumber SaladVinegar, salt, pepper, light extra virgin olive oil.
Next Up at Wayside
Thanksgiving Pre-Orders Open November 1.
Mark your calendar. Get your order in early, skip the holiday scramble, and actually enjoy your own Thanksgiving.